Awards Judging Categories

1. Overall Best Reviewer Award

• Awarded to the reviewer who consistently demonstrates exceptional quality, timeliness, and dedication in reviewing manuscripts.

2. Most Constructive Feedback Reviewer Award

• Recognizes reviewers who provide highly detailed, constructive, and actionable feedback that helps authors significantly improve their manuscripts.

3. Most Active Reviewer Award

• For the reviewer who handles the highest number of manuscripts within a given timeframe, while maintaining high-quality reviews.

4. Best Timely Reviewer Award

• Awarded to a reviewer who consistently submits reviews on or before deadlines, enabling smooth and efficient processing of manuscripts.

5. Best Subject Expertise Reviewer Award

• Recognizes reviewers who provide highly specialized and expert reviews in their specific field, contributing to the journal's academic rigor.

6. Best Peer Review Contribution Reviewer Award

• The Best Peer Review Contribution Reviewer Award recognizes individuals who have made outstanding contributions through their peer review efforts. This award celebrates reviewers who demonstrate exceptional dedication, expertise, and professionalism in evaluating submissions.

7. Best Innovative Reviewer Award

• For reviewers who provide creative and innovative insights, suggesting novel approaches or perspectives to enhance the manuscript.

8. Best Interdisciplinary Reviewer Award

• Recognizes reviewers who contribute outstanding feedback to manuscripts that span multiple disciplines, demonstrating expertise across fields.